This site is an archive of the OneSpace Forums. Return to forum index.

Do single parents spoil their children?

Anna
Parenting specialist DoppleMe

Many single parents try to over-compensate for the fact that Daddy or Mummy is not around.
We may feel like we are always saying "No" to them, so tend to let them get away with some things, that we deem less important.
Our children may be spending their fortnightly weekends with their non-resident parent and having such a great time, that we feel that we have to compete with being the good guy.
As we have no one to share the decisions with and we are learning how to be a parent on our own, are we therefore spoiling them for a quieter life? Or are we stricter because we feel that we have to do the job of two people. Have your say here .............

Posted on: May 28, 2008 - 12:05pm
Nick

I wish I could spoil my son but unfortuanatley can't due to financial restrictions

Posted on: May 28, 2008 - 4:58pm
ficurnow

I know my ex likes to play the 'parental top trumps' game with expensive presents and foreign holidays because he can afford to - he earns so much more than I do; because I've chosen to shape my job around my kids there's really no way I'll ever do more than just about make ends meet and both my kids and I know that. But fortunately they're mature enough to know that they can't expect endless consumer goodies from me but they can expect me to be there for them - for love and consistency and understanding. Fi x

Posted on: June 14, 2008 - 10:46am
wiseowl

My daughters dad sends her money through the post randomly,he hasn't seen her for 5 years but seems to think that £70 will compensate for that. She always thinks that its great, but does know that its no substitution for love and being around. I must say it means that she can get the Converse trainers that she wants! but she never knows when it is coming again. I don't spoil her financially cos i can't but i do probably overdo the I love you thing and you are so great and my clever girl etc, which is spoiling to some extent i guess but its a fine line between spoiling and raising self esteem, dont u think??

Posted on: June 14, 2008 - 11:02am
ficurnow

No - I think good for you, wiseowl (!) You can't tell your daughter you love her too many times. Sounds to me you're doing a great job for her self esteem, not spoiling her. Fi x

Posted on: June 14, 2008 - 4:57pm
wiseowl

Thanks Fi, that's good to hear. She is pretty well behaved most of the time, it's only when i see her around kids from two parent families and i wonder if i overindulge her, i guess we just have such a different relationship, there isn't another adult to share life with, so i share it with her. I treat her as an equal not as one of the children, maybe this is spoiling her, but c'est la vie, that's just the way it is........

Posted on: June 18, 2008 - 9:03pm
pen

Hi, how I can I make thing get better, how i can make my children happer? beacuse I work three days a week and I drive everywear pic them up from schkool, and shopping, visiting a frirnds take them to a birthadys parties and, all that I kill my salfe every days. And they dosent preashate at all. I don;t know what to do? Is there any slotion I can make every things better in future? please I need helpe from someone. money problems as well, the money I get only smal amount is not enough I'm stuc, my family they not helping me at all, I'm my own, doing everything my self I'm getting mad. I need halpe? is any one how can helpe me, also we are saperate three years father do come to see them when ever he want to , when he dose with them he let them watch T V, then they dosent lisnt to me they think now they can do what they want,this is really make me mad

Posted on: September 16, 2008 - 11:29am
Anna
Parenting specialist DoppleMe

Dear Pen

You sound very distressed, you seem to be doing everything for your children for very little in return. You ask how you can make the children happier when it sounds as if you are doing everything that you can.

How old are your children? And where do you live? Perhaps I can find some local support for you, or use our Advice Finder on the One Space homepage http://advicefinder.onespace.org.uk/

As parents we can't always expect our children to appreciate everything we do for them, but we do need to teach them the value of what we do.

The older the children get the more they need to assert their own independance, but they also need to learn that a relationship is a 2 way thing. Sometimes we have to be cruel to be kind. If your children don't show you respect, tell them you won't drive them somewhere that they request.

If your children are older you can hold a family discussion where everyone has a chance to say how they are feeling at the moment (with no interruptions allowed from others) and then as a family, discuss how you can resolve and help each other. Remind your children that families are supposed to support one another. Let them know how you are feeling, without getting cross, just matter of factly. If they will support you then you can continue to support them with what they want to do.

You could have a written contract between you and them, for example, if they wash up after dinner, you will take them to party at the weekend. Or if they help around the house, they can stay out an extra hour.

Remember - YOUR HOUSE - YOUR RULES

Is it possible to talk to your childrens father? Ask him to support you with disciplining them?

As for money, you should be entitled to some sort of maintenance from their father, have a look at http://www.cmoptions.org/maintenance/index.html and go to your local Job Centre and talk to the Lone Parent Advisor.

Good Luck Pen, come back and tell us how it is going.

Posted on: September 18, 2008 - 12:11pm
lovelysb

I'm with wiseowl . I don't do the materalistic spoiling, but do spoil with love and praise. I think that it is healthy and I don't know about wiseowl but I find that because I praise and acknowledge the good behaviour so much, he tends to behave himself as he doesn't want to hear the reverse.

Please don't shout or gang up on me (ducks for cover), but I think that many people who spoil their children materaliscally usually do it more for themselves than the child - guilt, pity...whatever (unless they have won the lottery and all rules go out the window..."buy a wii console for ever room what the heck...we can live off the interest"..lol). I'd be failing my son by over indulging in material goods for the sake of it, as that will not teach him anything about the real world. Treats, special treats have to be earnt, through school work/hardwork, attitude, behaviour, generosity, chores etc (and that's just the catogeries on my star chart!! LOL)

In terms of over complensating beause your a single parent. This may sound hard faced....its not my responsibility to make guilty gestures (through the purse) to complenstate for somebody who chooses not to take part in their childs life. What is my responsibility to be the best parent that I can be to the best of my ability, which is a learning process for both me and little man... good cop and bad cop are a part of good parenting regardless if its a two parent relationship or one - boundries!

I was raised by a lone parent so I see it from both sides of the coin, from my experience and from the convos I have with my little man I know that love, time, committment and sacrafice outways material goods. They might not see that straight away but they will by the time they grow up.

Posted on: October 2, 2008 - 9:15pm
Clarebear

Hi all,

I 'spoil' my daughter, I know I do, but I don't do it intentionally because I work, or because I am on my own. I do it because if it's in my remit, it's nice to do so. I am a great believer in time is worth more than money, but still see things and think 'Emmie would love that', so buy it because I can, not because there is a birthday or anything coming up. I know I'm probably making a rod for my own back, but I was bought up in a very strict household, so maybe am compensating for this? I make Emmie do her own tidying and include her with the cleaning and washing, and she gets pennies for that. If she buys a magazine when I have previously said no, she pays for it with her own money. So I do try and get her to realise the value of money, and once it's gone, there is no more. But, she has manic birthday parties, and we have a large garden with amazing toys in there. Trying to impress upon her that she is very lucky, and that not every little girl has all this stuff is difficult. My parents are quite comfortably off, so for both childrens birthdays, they bought a large wooden climbing frame (off ebay, and i arranged transport) because that is way better than a Wiiiiii (or whatever they are called lol).

Her father pays me b*gger all, and I had to fight for that, but when she has weekends with him, she tends to get everything she wants, purely for an easy life.

My addition to this thread, is that she is now comparing people's attractiveness to her, by the amount of gifts she gets from them. ie: Daddy always buys her presents, but her Nanny and Grandad, who do an emormous amount of things with her, don't buy her presents every week, so she doesn't want to have sleepovers, as she knows she won't get a 'present'.

Have I kind of asked for this from my daughter? Or is this a normal 5 year old thing where they can't quite see that hours with grandad in the park is worth more than a new doll and being left to play with it without any interaction? Both my parents and I spend hours doing crafty things with her, and painting, and non-cost things, but she has still got this 'unless it's a bought present, it's not fun'. Only recently this has happened, so any ideas would be gratefully received.

Clarey xxxxxxxxxx

Posted on: November 3, 2008 - 9:08pm
Anna
Parenting specialist DoppleMe

Hi lovelysb, sorry I have taken so long in replying to your response, you sound like you are very much in the control of the situation and are taking a sensible stance on not spoiling your child materialistically.

It is very true that if you praise and acknowledge good behaviour, our children tend to behave themselves as they don't want to hear the reverse.

I am going to embolden the above so we don't forget it. It is one of the first and most important ground rules of discipline.

Thanks lovelysb

Posted on: November 24, 2008 - 1:59pm
Anna
Parenting specialist DoppleMe

Hi Clarebear,

Children between the ages of 2-5years are at a developmental stage where they have a self-centred view of the world, "what I want is fair", they want everything for themselves, they manipulate, tell lies and cheat at games to get their own way, without understanding that these behaviours are wrong!

It is our job as parent to teach them that there are rules that they need to follow.

Keep talking to your daughter about how the best presents in the world are free - hugs, kisses, fun time - things that she can give you and make you happy. You could discuss how having nothing in the world would be ok as long as you had each other, talk about if Grandad didn't want to take her to the park anymore, how would she feel? You could have a session in her room clearing out all the old things and taking them to the charity shop so she learns that other children don't have as much as she does and those children are still valuable, loved and happy.

Do remember that when you are talking to her she will be understanding what you are saying, but she might not be able to reason it on her own. As long as you stay on this vain during her childhood, she will learn to be empathetic and hopefully recognise the value of someone giving her quality time rather than money/materials. Also watch what you talk about, often we might go on and on about money, not having enough, or being jealous of someone who has more, or ungrateful for a rubbish present! Our children are forever modelling our behaviour, its how they learn!

She is very lucky to have a large wooden climbing frame and great grandparents and she shouldn't be made to feel guilty for that at all, however it is good that she learns that she is very fortunate and privileged.

I think if your parents spend so much time with her, she most definitely will learn to value their time, maybe not right now, but in the future those will be memories that she will keep. Don't beat yourself up about it, her father is giving you the perfect tools to teach her what you want her to know.

Good Luck, let me know how you get on :)

Posted on: November 24, 2008 - 2:21pm